| 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | |||
| Annapolis Hawks | Annapolis Hawks | Annapolis Hawks | Annapolis Hawks | |||
| BBL Elite | BBL Elite | BBL Elite | BBL Elite | |||
| Blue Star | Blue Star | Carolina 24/7 | Blue Star | |||
| Cannons | Carolina 24/7 | DC Express | Brotherly Love (Zeus) | |||
| Carolina 24/7 | Edge | Edge | DC Express | |||
| Express North (Brameier) | Express North (Tracy) | Express North (Kirkaldy) | Edge | |||
| Express North (Reda) | FCA Maryland | FCA Maryland | Express North (Brameier) | |||
| FCA Maryland | Fighting Clams | Fighting Clams | FCA Maryland | |||
| Fighting Clams | Green Turtle | HardCor | Igloo | |||
| Iron Horse | Igloo | Igloo | Iron Horse | |||
| Juiced Cherries | Iron Horse | Iron Horse | Juiced Cherries | |||
| Legacy | Juiced Cherries | Juiced Cherries | Legacy | |||
| Madlax – Capital | Legacy | Legacy | Looneys | |||
| NH Tomahawks | Madlax – Capital | LI Express (Chanenchuk) | Madlax – Capital | |||
| Orange Crush | NH Tomahawks | Madlax – Capital | NH Tomahawks | |||
| Patriot | Orange Crush | NH Tomahawks | Orange Crush | |||
| PLC | Patriot | Orange Crush | Patriot | |||
| Predators | Predators | Patriot | PLC | |||
| Prime Time | Prime Time | Predators | Predators | |||
| Rising Sons | Rising Sons | Prime Time | Prime Time | |||
| South Shore | South Shore | Rising Sons | South Shore | |||
| Sweetlax – NY | Sweetlax – NY | South Shore | Sweetlax – NY | |||
| Tenacious Turtles | Sweetlax Krakens | Sweetlax – NY | ||||
| Tri-State | Tri-State | Tri-State | ||||
| 2024 | 2025 | 2026 | 2027 | |||
| Annapolis Hawks | Annapolis Hawks | Annapolis Hawks | BBL Elite | |||
| BBL Elite | BBL Elite | Arden Diamondbacks | Legacy | |||
| Blue Star | Carolina Miners | BBL Elite | Madlax | |||
| Brotherly Love (Hercules) | Edge | Carolina Miners | Predators | |||
| Carolina Miners | Express North (Morgan) | Express North | Prime Time | |||
| Edge | Igloo | Legacy | Sweetlax – NY | |||
| Express North (Schreiber) | Legacy | Madlax | Tribal | |||
| FCA Maryland | LI Express (Chanenchuk) | Predators | ||||
| Legacy | Madlax | Prime Time | ||||
| LI Express (Schwalje) | Orange Crush | South Shore | 2028 | |||
| Madlax | Predators | Sweetlax – NY | BBL | |||
| Orange Crush | Prime Time | Towerman | Igloo | |||
| Predators | South Shore | Tri-State | Legacy | |||
| Prime Time | Sweetlax – NY | Madlax | ||||
| South Shore | Tri-State | Sweetlax – NY | ||||
| Sweetlax – NY | Tribal |
